I would highly recommend staying at Cruz Bay Boutique to anyone looking for a few nights on St. John. The staff is very welcoming, the location is super convenient (a few minutes from the ferry and taxi hub), and includes coffee/food in the morning to help start your day. There are many restaurants in a walkable area near the hotel, including a fabulous steakhouse called Dave & Jerry's that's literally next door. Be aware that the rooms are fairly small (especially the shower), there is no pool, and that you may need to climb stairs. That said, the rooms were clean and comfortable, the AC worked, and checkin/checkout was hassle free.